SMAT fires up to open SLS acoustic testing

by Chris Bergin

The Scale Model Acoustic Test (SMAT) – a mini-me version of the SLS – has fired up for the first time at the Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC). The tests are focused on providing data to engineering teams who are tasked with designing the Sound Suppression System that will protect the Heavy Lift Launch Vehicle (HLV) from the acoustical energy of launch.

SMAT Test:

Followers of the Space Shuttle Program will be well versed in how one of the key events during the final seconds of the countdown was the flood of water being thrown over the Mobile Launch Platform (MLP).

Z12Known as the Sound Suppression System, 300,000 gallons of water – stored in a 290-foot-high, 300,000 gallon tank – was released in stages, initially just prior to the Space Shuttle Main Engines (SSMEs) ramping up to full power and then at full flow at Solid Rocket Booster (SRB) ignition.

The water flowed down the tower located at the pad complex and out through six 12-foot-high quench nozzles, known as “rainbirds”, reducing acoustical levels within the orbiter payload bay to about 142 decibels, below the design requirement of 145 decibels.

Without this system, the soundwaves of the engines firing would bounce back off the MLP zero deck and impact the orbiter, risking damage to the vehicle at the worst possible time.

The Space Launch System (SLS) will also require the protection of the Sound Suppression System ahead of its launches from Pad 39B at the Kennedy Space Center (KSC).

SMATHowever, the system has to be tailor made for the monster rocket, with data being provided via the Scale Model Acoustic Test (SMAT) firings.

“We can verify the launch environments the SLS vehicle was designed around and determine the effectiveness of the sound suppression systems,” noted Doug Counter, technical lead for the acoustic testing.

“Scale model testing on the space shuttle was very comparable to what actually happened to the vehicle at liftoff. That’s why we do the scale test.”

SMAT Sound Suppression System, via L2Preparations for a series of SMAT tests began in 2012 at Marshall’s test stand 116, with the construction of a working scaled down water-based sound suppression system.

“This water system will be used during the planned hot fire testing series that is planned for SMAT, which utilizes small-scale solid rocket Boosters and Lox-Hydrogen thrusters,” noted L2’s rolling SLS updates at the time.

“Based on discussions with NASA/KSC Ground Systems Development and Operations (GSDO) engineers, MSFC is satisfied that this properly represents the water flow rates and coverage of the full-scale system and will meet the test needs for SMAT.”

Click here for SLS Articles:

As with the tests on the previous vehicles, the data will provide a good baseline ahead of the actual SLS firing into life later this decade.

Z9The SMAT article itself is the most technically advanced sub-scale rocket ever to be used on such a test. It will provide an array of critical data to SLS engineers.

“Ignition overpressure (IOP) is a significant transient low-frequency pressure event caused by the rapid pressure rise rate of the solid rocket motor,” opened an extensive presentation on the SMAT (L2).

“Lift-off acoustics (LOA) noise is caused by the supersonic steady jet flow interaction with surrounding atmosphere and launch complex, persisting for 0-20 seconds as the vehicle lifts off.

Z11“Scale Model Acoustic Test (SMAT) objectives: Verify predicted LOA environments, obtain data to update the lift-off acoustic environments.

“Verify predicted IOP environments, obtain data for use in IOP analytical models for updated environments, and improve IOP analytical models.

“Verify SLS deflector design. Characterize Ground Acoustic (GA) environments, provide data to support GA environment predictions. Obtain Spatial Correlation (SC) data for use in vibro-acoustic models. Obtain data for Computation Fluid Dynamics (CFD) validation, and evaluate water sound suppression systems, determine water suppression attenuation.”

Z6The tests will ramp up over time, with the opening SMAT firing – which lasted five seconds – involving an article that was without its twin imitation boosters.

Instead, SMAT began testing with small thrusters of its aft, mimicking the RS-25D (Space Shuttle Main Engines) that will be placed on the core of the real life SLS.

These thrusters – similar to vintage hardware originally designed in the 1960’s and tested during the Space Shuttle program – successfully met all test objectives during Phase I scale model acoustic testing last year at Marshall’s Test Stand 115.

SMAT Thruster Dev, via L2Fabrication then began for a “fourthruster cluster” set, mirroring the four RS-25s that will power all versions of SLS’ core stage. They were fabricated by Aerojet Rocketdyne.

“Hot-fire testing was initiated for the thrusters that will simulate the Core Stage Engines for the Scale Model Acoustic Test (SMAT). All four thrusters have been tested together for the first time in a single cluster in the same configuration that will be used for the Core Stage of the SMAT model,” added SLS’ rolling update section (L2) last year.

“Testing conducted at Test stand 115 in the Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) East Test area. The first start ignition test was conducted on March 7, 2013. Two low thrust main stage tests were conducted on March 8, 2013. All test hardware is in excellent condition so far and (will continue testing during the Spring).”

The test series will attempt to simulate a lift-off, without the SMAT model actually launching.

Z7Also, as expected, the test vehicle is heavily instrumented, with five primary instrumentation suites resulting in over 325 sensors on the SMAT rocket.

It is outfitted with B&K 4944-B microphones, pressure transducers on the tower/mobile launcher – which is also a scaled model of the actual ML currently being converted from its role with Ares I to SLS.

It includes far field measurement devices, accelerometers, thermocouples and strain gauges on vehicle, thermocouples, flow meters and chamber pressure instrumentation.

Acoustic Testing:

SMAT continues the heritage of testing future launch vehicles at the scale model level.

NASA engineers have test fired many versions of scaled rockets to gain data on the acoustic environments endured during ignition and launch.

The primary source of the acoustic field is the fluctuating turbulence in the mixing region of the rocket exhaust flow – known as Engine Generated Acoustics.

Engine generated noise is a function of the exhaust flow parameters, launch stand configuration, and to a lesser extent atmospheric conditions.

Preliminary estimates of the engine generated acoustics at a specified location on the vehicle can be determined by scaling measured acoustic data from previous launch vehicle programs, taking into account the above mentioned flow, configuration, and atmospheric parameters.

The 6.4 Percent Scale Shuttle, via L2A better definition of the lift-off acoustic environment can be determined from hot fire testing of dynamically scaled models of the launch vehicle and stand.

During the Space Shuttle development program, a 6.4 percent scale model of the launch vehicle, propulsion system, launch stand, and exhaust duct system with water suppression was used to refine the analytical/scaling estimates of the lift-off acoustic environment.

The resulting data provides a very useful template for the full scale rocket, although final verification of the environment is only fully provided by full static firings or launches of the actual vehicle.

Notably, the debut launch of the Space Shuttle Program (SSP) – with Columbia on STS-1 – showed the importance of understanding the acoustic environments, as the orbiter’s heat shield was damaged when an overpressure wave from the SRBs caused a forward RCS oxidizer strut to fail. Her body flap was also pushed five degrees out of position.

STS-129 FRR Evaluation Slide, via L2The subject was also raised during STS-129’s Flight Readiness Review (FRR), as a potential issue with a very small area of the orbiter – known as a stinger attach point between the RCS and OMS Pod – raised concerns that recent acoustic environment analysis of the Space Shuttle Main Engines (SSMEs) during ignition could cause stressing that potentially leads to cracks in the attach pins/stinger.

Although those concerns were based on old and overly conservative data, managers showed their usual due diligence in gathering an array of updated information, via new computational models, borescope inspections on the fleet, and the installation of sensors in the area in question – all of which would be used to completely allay the potential fear of life fatigue on the stinger.

Click here for FRR Articles:

Notably, the FRR presentations noted they lacked key historical data, given the 6.4 percent model tested during the 1970s only fired motors that mimicked the Solid Rocket Boosters and not the SSMEs, while Main Engine Ignition (MEI) Acoustic & SSME Ignition Overpressure (IOP) Environment data was classed as “continually evolving” during the 30 years of the program – leading to the concern ahead of STS-129.

ASMAT With Ares I modelThe vehicle that was set to replace the Space Shuttle, Ares I, also underwent IOP testing – with the Ares I Scale Model Acoustics Test (ASMAT) tested during 2010.

Numerous tests, each using a different pad configuration – such as with and without water bags within the launch mount – were conducted at MSFC.

For the Ares I Scale Modelling Acoustic Tests, the vehicle model was set at a number of fixed elevations for individual test firings, these being 0, 2.5, 5.0, 7.5, and 10.0 feet. Based on the scale of the ASMAT, these distances corresponded to full-scale elevations of 0, 50, 100, 150, and 200 feet.

Quick look test results indicated that the overall noise levels measured on the vehicle were within predicted ranges and the data compared favorably between the firings. However, Ares I was cancelled shortly after the ASMAT firings.

SLS SMAT, via L2The SMAT firings will continue over the coming months, with the vehicle soon to sport its two “boosters”, in the form of two ATK-built Rocket-Assisted Take Off (RATO) motors will simulate SLS boosters, with the test requirement calling for the motors ignite simultaneously, as the SRBs would during launch.

This testing will provide critical data about how the powerful noise generated by the engines and boosters may affect the rocket and crew, especially during liftoff, with a focus on how low- and high-frequency sound waves impact on the vehicle.

(Images via NASA and L2)

(NSF and L2 are continuing to provide the most extensive and exclusive SLS coverage. To join L2, support the site and access a huge database of content, click here:

Related Articles